Finding the right travel management solution for your business needs can seem like a tough task. You want a solution that offers expense tracking capabilities, credit card integration, automation functionalities, and more.
Here, we’ll be comparing some of the top TMCs: Egencia and TravelActions. We’ll see what works, what doesn’t, and what real-life users say about them.
As a bonus we’ll also introduce you to an alternative to both of these, that could provide exactly what you’re looking for in a modern TMC. Stay tuned for more.
Egencia is a corporate travel management company recently acquired by American Express Global Business Travel (AMEX). It’s a solution for big and medium companies who need to send their employees around the world.
It positions itself as a solution to help businesses manage risk, boost traveler well-being, and maximize ROI in business travel. Additionally, it supports six languages and is used in 60 countries.
According to Egencia, their top features include:
- Eco-friendly travel program: to reduce carbon emissions for greener corporate travel.
- Duty of care and risk management: to ensure the welfare of your employees from the moment they book until the moment they return home.
- VAT recovery and reimbursement: so you can save on your travel budget.
- COVID-19 response: protect your employees wherever they go and comply with COVID-19 safety measurements.
What Egencia users say:
User reviews of Egencia praise how easy and intuitive it is. Users of the platform like how they can book everything from the same place, and easily compare flights and hotels.
“It is a really easy platform to use for booking flights, hotels, and rental cars, amongst other things.” - Courtney K., review from G2
“It consolidates all of the flights available into one view that I can filter down into specific requirements I have (time/day/cost/etc).” - Review from Capterra
However, not everything is good news for Egencia’s users. Many complain about the mobile app features and loading speed and overall there are some improvements they would like to see.
“In today's day and age, you need an app that is easy to use, fast & has all of the functions the desktop site has. This does not.” - Scott K., review from Capterra
“I wish they included a few more budget flight options. Sometimes I'm able to find way cheaper flights on Expedia from recognized carriers that aren't in Egencia.” - Anthony M., review from G2
“My coworker and I had to call Egencia to get receipts for our hotel stay and had to wait on hold for 20 minutes other than that they are great!” - Daniel L., review from G2
When looking at the overall performance of Egencia, it does the job. However, there are some mobile app and customer service improvements that are urgently needed by their users. They also don’t offer a free trial—not ideal for small companies.
Navan is a full travel and expense management platform. It helps businesses of all sizes with policy compliance, online booking, mobile travel solutions, expense reports, traveler notifications, and more.
Its AI technology provides useful recommendations based on your company’s policies, real-time insights on your employee travel spending, and a comprehensive business travel management experience.
Navan says their top features include:
- Sustainable travel management: enabling you to reduce your company’s carbon footprint.
- Large inventory: so you can find the hotels and airlines that meet your needs.
- AI-powered technology: increases savings by finding the cheapest deals and recommending the services you really need.
- Corporate card management: to ensure you’re always in control by weaving policy into corporate card spend and automating reporting.
What Navan users say:
Navan users think the software is fairly easy to use once you get used to its features, which users report can take a bit of time. However, once getting to grips with the software, users report how useful the insights that the platform provides are.
“The different products are hard to understand initially but once you figure that out it is relatively easy to use.” - Clyde A., review from Capterra
Although some users give it some good feedback, many have some valid complaints about the platform. For example, some travelers complain about the integrations with the airlines and other apps which seem to harm its overall booking tool functionality.
Some users also complain about the organization of the search results which can make it confusing.
“I had to purchase two one-way tickets because the round trip options did not allow me to book the flights at the times that I wanted.” - Kyle K., review from G2
“Add-ons aren't able to be booked through Navan, which means if the only seats available are economy, you can't add the ability to choose seats or pay for checked bags in the app. You have to pay for those separately and be reimbursed.” - Grace H., review from G2
“I did find myself using my airplane's app for real-time flight notifications instead of Navan.” - Brenton D., review from G2
Another problem that some users report is the approval workflow and process being clunky and not optimized for streamlined booking.
“The only hurdle can be that the trips have to be approved by an approver prior to going to the booking page.” - Review from Capterra
Navan is a versatile travel and expense management company. Although it has some advantages, the problems in its functionality, mobile app, and its hard-to-understand onboarding process can be a dealbreaker for some.
A fresh alternative: TravelPerk
Now that we’ve seen what Egencia and Navan can do, let’s look at a TMC that we think is better suited for the job, and with more praise given in well-deserved reviews: TravelPerk.
TravelPerk is a top-rated all-in-one travel management software. It was developed to give travelers and their managers the freedom and control they need for seamless travel booking. TravelPerk is a strong alternative to Egencia and Navan, combining the best of both solutions.
TravelPerk offers a seamless travel management experience by providing expense management software, travel risk and duty of care management, flexible travel options, and more.
It’s not without good reason that Revolut, Grammarly, Uber, and other big companies put their trust in TravelPerk when it comes to making their travel management effortless and carefree.
TravelPerk also integrates with other apps like Expensify, BambooHR, Mobileexpense, Ramp, and many more. This allows users to take travel management to the next level by integrating with their pre-existing platforms and workflows.
TravelPerk’s concierge services, real-time notifications, and intuitive software give you all the services that an entire travel agency would provide–all on one platform. Plus, unlike Egencia and Navan—TravelPerk doesn’t charge a subscription fee. You only pay when you travel.
TravelPerk’s top features include:
- Industry-leading travel inventory: to find your corporate travelers the best deals on the market—low cost included. TravelPerk’s negotiated rates ensure you won't find a better deal elsewhere.
- Great traveler autonomy & flexibility with 100% compliance: to get your traveler where they need to be within the boundaries of your travel policy.
- Top-rated customer service–available 24/7: whatever happens, know that TravelPerks’ team is there for you—all day, every day.
- FlexiPerk: guarantees at least 80% of users' money refunded when canceling up to 2-hours before departure.
- GreenPerk: offset your carbon footprint by investing in sustainable initiatives sourced by the TravelPerk Sustainability team.
Let’s see what TravelPerk users say about the platform.
What TravelPerk users say:
TravelPerk users praise the user-friendly interface and above-and-beyond customer support team. They also like how budget-friendly the pay-as-you-travel service is, and enjoy the low-cost pricing options that it offers.
“What I liked the most was having the app on the mobile and offline to show my tickets. The platform is easy to use, and with just a few clicks, you can create your trip.” - Marta P. review from G2
"Product is very intuitive for travelers to book travel that is within the companies’ budget and travel programs. The approval flow is extremely simple and centralized billing is super easy. The concierge service is great." - Fraser H., review from SoftwareAdvice
Another feature that users love is the possibility to see where colleagues have stayed before. This gives them a better idea of what to expect, and the chance to ask around for recommendations.
Let’s have a look at a head-to-head comparison of these three travel management solutions for you to make a final decision:
|Governance and control||Excellent||Poor||Excellent|
|Reporting & analytics||Moderate||Moderate||Excellent|
|Duty of Care||Moderate||Moderate||Excellent|
Taking off with TravelPerk
After comparing these three travel management platforms we can see the pros and cons of each, with user reviews being the ultimate proof of value.
While other TMCs do their job and offer an adequate experience to their users, TravelPerk demonstrates outstanding performance. TravelPerk offers everything you need from your corporate travel management solution.
Ready to manage your corporate travel needs seamlessly? Sign up today, and start traveling with TravelPerk.
Make business travel simpler. Forever.
See our platform in action. Trusted by thousands of companies worldwide, TravelPerk makes business travel simpler to manage with more flexibility, full control of spending with easy reporting, and options to offset your carbon footprint.
Find hundreds of resources on all things business travel, from tips on traveling more sustainably, to advice on setting up a business travel policy, and managing your expenses. Our latest e-books and blog posts have you covered.
Never miss another update. Stay in touch with us on social for the latest product releases, upcoming events, and articles fresh off the press.